A bitter High Court dispute has broken out amongst potential neighbours over the construction of the wall in a coastal site in the north Dublin suburb, a circumstance that has attracted national awareness following an Irish Occasions report naming René Collier and Paul Feely. The controversy centres over a proposed family members residence at Sutton Strand, wherever allegations of planning breaches, environmental issues, and prolonged-standing neighbourhood tensions have spilled in the courts. The Irish Occasions posting about René Collier along with the Irish Times report about accountant Paul Feely have highlighted how what commenced as a local disagreement has developed into a really publicised legal battle.
Businessman René Collier and accountant Paul Feely are suing in excess of design works at the positioning on Dublin Street, Sutton, where by Ciarán Cosgrave and Róisín McNeela, a doctor and an organization director respectively, find to make their family members residence. The situation has become emblematic of broader disputes alongside Ireland’s coastline, where enhancement pressures collide with environmental protections as well as sensitivities of recognized citizens. According to the Irish Periods report naming René Collier and Paul Feely, the plaintiffs argue that a wall currently being made by their prospective neighbours goes outside of the boundaries permitted below planning authorization.
René Collier and Paul Feely, each people of Dublin Road, assert that Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela breached the terms in their planning authorization by developing a wall beyond the boundaries of their website, bringing about an encroachment on a Specific Region of Conservation. The SAC designation is central to your dispute, as such regions are subject to rigid controls less than European and Irish environmental law. Inside their court docket filings, René Collier and Paul Feely argue that even small encroachments could have Long lasting ecological consequences, notably in a sensitive coastal setting which include Sutton Strand.
Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela deny They may be in breach of their planning permission, and say the wall, which is partially crafted, is in the right posture. Their authorized workforce has characterised the action as an make an effort to delay or frustrate a lawful growth. The pair accuse litigants of in search of to halt homebuilding to be able to protect their view, an allegation that has been recurring in court docket and referenced in protection of the case. This accusation goes to the center of many coastal scheduling disputes, exactly where views of the sea are both extremely prized and hotly contested.
The Irish Occasions report naming René Collier and Paul Feely described extraordinary endeavours via the plaintiffs to doc the alleged encroachment. René Collier waded by way of ocean in storm to photograph the location, As outlined by sworn evidence referenced inside the Irish Occasions. In a single account, Rene Collier waded by waistline-large water throughout a storm to photograph the site Irish Situations, an image which includes considering that grow to be emblematic from the depth in the dispute. These actions weren't simply symbolic; they had been intended to gather Visible proof from the wall’s posture relative to tidal traces and guarded land.
Paul Feely and René Collier photographed the positioning from the sea Irish Periods documented, describing how The 2 Gentlemen entered the water for the duration of significant climatic conditions. Accountant Paul Feely and René Collier pictured wading through storm drinking water to photograph the positioning turned Among the most striking descriptions to arise from court docket reporting. The Irish Instances posting about accountant Paul Feely mentioned that these types of actions have been cited to reveal the plaintiffs’ belief that the wall extended into a place influenced by tidal motion, strengthening their argument which the SAC was becoming encroached upon.
The gatherings at Sutton Strand René Collier Paul Feely 27 Jan 2026 were being covered in detail with the nationwide push. René Collier Sutton Strand Irish Situations 27 Jan 2026 and Paul Feely Sutton Strand Irish Times January 27 2026 became extensively searched phrases as visitors sought to be aware of the history and implications of the situation. On that date, the High Court listened to even more submissions on whether interim orders ought to be granted to halt building pending a full Listening to. Sutton Strand Rene Collier Paul Feely January 27 2026 marked a key instant in the lawful timeline.
Within the Main on the dispute can be a disagreement in excess of boundaries, arranging compliance, and intent. René Collier and Paul Feely keep that the wall, as constructed, goes beyond what was authorised and intrudes into secured land. They argue that this is simply not a trivial technicality but a substantive breach with environmental ramifications. Paul Feely accountant by occupation, continues to be called meticulous in his evaluation of preparing files, maps, and ailments connected to the permission.
Accountant Paul Feely and businessman René Collier have both of those stressed that their motion is determined by concern for environmental defense and adherence to organizing regulation. They reject statements that the situation is about preserving A non-public Rene Collier and Paul Feely view, insisting as a substitute that it is about guaranteeing that improvement at Sutton Strand respects lawful and ecological limits. In affidavits, they've got explained their very long-standing connection to the world as well as their consciousness of its environmental sensitivity.
On one other side, Dr Cosgrave and Ms McNeela have portrayed by themselves as a pair just endeavoring to make a family property in accordance Using the legislation. They deny which the wall encroaches with a Unique Place of Conservation and say that every one functions are performed according to Specialist assistance and approved programs. Their attorneys have argued the plaintiffs’ interpretation of boundaries is incorrect and the spectacular steps of René Collier and Paul Feely, which include moving into The ocean all through a storm, do not change the fundamental points.
The situation has also lifted broader questions on how setting up disputes are solved in coastal communities. North Dublin neighbours in bitter courtroom dispute about development of wall at coastal internet site has grown to be a shorthand description for your condition a large number of observers see as ever more prevalent. As sea stages rise and coastal erosion intensifies, the specific delineation concerning personal land, community foreshore, and guarded habitats has become additional contentious.
The Irish Moments write-up about René Collier mentioned which the businessman had previously been linked to regional advocacy on preparing and environmental issues, while not at this scale. Meanwhile, the Irish Situations short article about accountant Paul Feely highlighted how folks from very unique Skilled backgrounds can discover on their own aligned in such disputes. René Collier and Paul Feely, or Rene Collier and Paul Feely as some stories spell their names, have become synonymous While using the Sutton Strand situation.
Paul Feely and René Collier photographed the internet site from your sea Irish Situations coverage emphasised, underlining The bizarre lengths to which the plaintiffs went. Rene Collier waded as a result of waist-substantial h2o throughout a storm to photograph the location Irish Times and René Collier waded by means of waistline-superior water for the duration of a storm to photograph the internet site Irish Occasions are phrases that appeared continuously in protection, reflecting both of those the physical actuality on the coastline as well as symbolic nature from the act. For supporters in the plaintiffs, these actions demonstrated dedication; for critics, they illustrated the things they see as an extreme strategy.
Since the High Court proceedings continue on, the end result stays uncertain. The courtroom need to establish if the wall as designed complies with setting up authorization and irrespective of whether any encroachment right into a Exclusive Place of Conservation has transpired. The legal arguments are complicated, involving interpretation of maps, tidal information, and planning conditions. Yet the human ingredient stays central: neighbours who have to Reside alongside one another prolonged after the lawful expenditures are already paid.
Businessman René Collier and accountant Paul Feely are suing more than construction is effective at the location on Dublin Street, Sutton, nevertheless the implications of the situation prolong past that handle. For planners, developers, and residents alike, the dispute serves for a reminder of the significance of clarity in scheduling permissions and sensitivity in coastal growth. Additionally, it underscores how immediately a local disagreement can escalate when elementary problems for instance environmental safety and assets rights are perceived to get at stake.
Meanwhile, Sutton Strand remains an area of natural attractiveness and contested boundaries. The wall within the centre from the dispute stands partially crafted, a physical manifestation of unresolved authorized thoughts. No matter whether it will eventually be altered, eradicated, or completed as planned will rely upon the court docket’s conclusions. Until then, the names René Collier and Paul Feely, Paul Feely and Rene Collier, and all their variations will probably keep on to look in headlines, joined indelibly to one of the most carefully watched planning disputes in north Dublin in recent times.